Paying Patient Experts
You’ve heard the Chief xxx Officer saying, I don’t need to listen to patient experts, we’re all patients. Gee, what do you say to this inexperience? You’ve also heard the empathy and born-again drive of the Chief xxx Officer who has a chronic illness, was recently hospitalized, or is the caregiver of a family member with chronic illness. Nothing can replace the experience of spending a day in a hospital bed or navigating your neighborhood for a day in a wheelchair.
I attended the Society of Participatory Medicine’s first conference a couple of months ago. Some businesses making big money from patient data describing their volunteer patient advisory panels or providing gift cards to their patient experts. We’d like to pay more, but it’s what we can afford.
I’ve been a reviewer of funding requests since 2013 for Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI). PCORI pays all stakeholder reviewers (patients, clinicians, scientists, administrators) the same stipend-a reasonable amount.
In 2013 and 2014 funding applications I reviewed listed either no payment or $50 gift cards for patient stakeholders on their Research Advisory Boards. By 2016 many funding applications listed $500-$1000 stipends. In 2017 I saw an application that budgeted for the payment of respite care for caregiver experts’ carees. We’ve come a long way.
The US has a love-hate relationship with paying for value. It’s like the Golden Rule: easy to say, tough to do. Just look at the Trump-Ryan-McConnell tax bill. I digress… The healthcare industry values credentials as a proxy for knowledge- whether or not they know what the acronyms mean. Acronyms = expertise. Credentials usual mean deep expertise in a narrow subject. We willingly pay for deep and narrow with credentials. Patients can have deeper knowledge about a narrower subject than those credentialed. We don’t have a means to calculate that value nor a willingness to pay for it.
Patients, parents, and caregivers can have knowledge about a broad subject — life. They have invaluable expertise about the usability and impact of healthcare treatments, tasks, products, and workflows. In general, we don’t have a means to calculate that value nor a willingness to pay for that value.
I provide pro bono expertise (donating my time) as a patient/caregiver expert and I’ve charged and received monthly retainers and good and not so good hourly consulting rates. I’ve been coached to make my case:
My consulting rate is $xxx.
We can’t afford that!
What can you afford?
How about $xxx?
Then I can decide if it’s worth my time. I always say,
I can give you xx hours a month and no dollars. I will not deplete my household budget for pro bono work.
Lived experience + systems knowledge + communication skill have tremendous value! If so, is it worth paying for? If yes, how does the business or grant budget for it?
Are there ethical issues about paying patient experts?
1. If expertise has value, what does it say when we pay for some expertise and not for others? Is it discriminatory or just rude?
2. Most people on expert panels are paid by the organizations they work for. They attend as representatives of those organizations. Some of us are independent of any organization without salary. Is there a conflict of interest when some are paid to attend and others not?
3. Everyone has interest and a point of view. Most usually advocate from their lived experience and expertise. Some are good listeners and open.
4. minded. Good listening and open-minded are priceless. Should we pay more?
5. Organizations and projects could save considerable money by using people with lived experience. Should they share the savings with those advisors?
6. Ethics seem connected to transparency. Would it help to be transparent about the advice we use, offer, and pay for?
More and more patient experts are finding their voice and healthcare-related businesses are seeking that expertise. Several platforms support matchmaking: WEGOHealth Solutions, Savvy Cooperative, Expert Connect. (Transparency — I have a business relationship with WEGO and Savvy).
What has been your experience? How can we support each other in this expert journey?
Values for Managing Health - Danny van Leeuwen Health Hats
As I transition out of this episode of my life with the passing of my mom, I'm reflecting anew on being a blogger…
Life literacy - If you can't explain it to a six year old... - Danny van Leeuwen Health Hats
I pl ay baritone saxophone in community Latin and blues funk bands. Our professional musician leader teaches us the…